Menu Usability of Superratings.com.au

The good thing about improving the usability of websites is that often it doesn’t take a huge amount of effort to drastically increase the usability.

For example, I was recently browsing the Australian Superratings website where you can purchase reports about various Australian Superannuation Funds and how they compare on investment returns, service and fees. I was curious about the price of the reports, but I couldn’t find this information anywhere on the site! I realised I had to commence the checkout process, which involved creating a new user account, just to find out the price of a report, which is very annoying and unnecessary.

Whilst navigating the site, attempting to find the pricing, I started to quickly get annoyed by the menu design on the left of the site.

Superratings Menu Original

The problem I have is that only two of the menu options are actually menu options, the rest are links, and it isn’t clear which two of the eleven are the options! So what happens is that I hover over each and every link only to realise that nothing is going to happen. The right pointing arrow on each blue box implies that it is a menu option that will display another option.

When I come across a menu option, the grey sub menu links all have a left pointing arrow. I am not sure of the purpose of this arrow as the sub menus disappear as soon as I move my mouse away.

A two minute redesign gives something like this:

Superratings Menu Redesign

It’s now easy to see, at a glance, what are menu options and what are links. I have removed the left pointing arrows from the sub menu to make them all look like links.

This quick design improves things straight away and would be sufficient in my opinion. If I was redesigning this site and I had more time I would probably try to remove the sub menu options completely by doing a reorganisation using information architecture techniques, such as card sorting, with a small focus group.

Oh, and I’d make sure that report pricing is displayed prominently throughout the site so that I don’t have to dig in the first place.

The usability of home contents insurance quotes

Background

I tend to pay my bills for an entire year at a time. This means rather than having lots of small amounts coming out of my bank account each month, I have a few large bills every now and then that I pay. The added advantage is that each time a new bill comes for the coming year I take a quick moment to shop around and make sure I’m still getting a good deal.

Last week my new home contents insurance bill came. I think I am getting a good deal but it can’t hurt to check. I decided to check about six or so home contents insurances companies to compare their quotes. Only then did I realise how much web usability still sucks… and it’s 2008!

I don’t get to do much usability work these days so I thought I would do a quick and dirty usability review on here, inspired by the stylings of my favourite usability book called “Don’t Make Me Think!“.

Starting a new Quote

Great: Allianz Insurance – One click and you’re there!

How to get a quote

Not so great: BankWest – Six screens including a modal dialog that temporarily disables all your firefox tabs. Lots of clicks and loads of clutter. Yuck.

How to get a quote

Getting a quote – what I liked

To be honest, there wasn’t much that blew me away when looking at the various insurance quote screens. AAMI had two nice features.

The click to talk feature is neat. You put in your phone number and someone will call you straight away to discuss your query. This is both convenient and cost effective as some people don’t have easy access to a phone.

Click to talk

The flexi premium screen is a good idea. It shows all excess options and how much they cost. It’s nice to be able to compare and make a decision without going back and forth between screens.

AAMI Home Insurance Flexi Premium

Getting a quote – what I didn’t like

New Window Popups: The insurance quotes at most sites open in a new browser window (sans browser controls). This is annoying because I use tabs in firefox to switch between various pages. A new window means I can’t use these tabs as easily.

Opens in a new browser window

Drop down values: Some of the drop down values are unclear and inconsistent. There is often no help available for these too. For example, I live in an apartment block and I honestly don’t know what the building or roof is made of.

Drop down list values

Buggy Software/Unhelpful Error Messages: The BankWest quote displayed an fatal error “Potential Flood Postcode, Check Full Address” midway through the quote. Straight away I am confused: I’m not even applying for flood insurance. It doesn’t tell me my options. I can’t correct it. I try to go back, I can’t. I’m stuck. I quit.

Unhelpful error message

Non Standard Terminology: Six out of seven sites I looked at use the term “quote” which makes sense but NRMA insurance insist on using “estimate“. I’m not as confident with the term “estimate“.

Firefox Browser Compatibility

I try to only use Firefox (2.0.0.13) as it is cross platform and open source. Some sites still won’t support it though. I simply don’t bother with quotes from these sites, they obviously don’t want my business.

AAMI: OK
Allianz: OK
ANZ: Session Timeout Error – Won’t work

BankWest: OK
NRMA: OK
Suncorp: OK
Western QBE: Must use IE.

Conclusion

The usability of the sites I looked at is not very good. Of the seven sites I looked at I only managed to get three quotes!

Most of the quotes I got were roughly the same price, so really my decision comes down to how pleased I am with the quote process. It shows you that in a fairly level playing field that good usability does really count.

Seek.com.au Rocks

I use the web a lot but I am still impressed by a little unexpected nicety.

Seek‘s maintenance message is one such thing. Instead of just telling me that Seek is down (so there!), they offer me three things to do instead of using seek at that moment. These are well worded and include expanding my skills, looking for my own business, or my favourite is offering me a game of pacman, right there, directly in the maintenance page!

Seek Unavailable


(Click to view full size)

I was also impressed with Seek when i recently emailed them a suggested improvement. Within hours i received a response saying its a great idea and thanks to people like me Seek gets better all the time. Two weeks Six months ago I emailed realestate.com.au with a site gripe, and I still haven’t heard from them at all.